Josh Levinger

Adventures at home, abroad, and online

Dissent is Patriotic

“Whose streets? Our streets.” The chants at the massive demonstrations against the Republican National Convention in New York City last Sunday were usually as short, but rarely as true as the above. Half a million people and I took over two miles of Seventh Avenue from Union Square to Madison Square Garden; several thousand then made their separate ways to Central Park for a gathering in defiance of a city ruling that it would destroy the grass. The biggest demonstrations ever during a political convention showed that at least some in this generation haven’t succumbed to apathy.

Various actions continued through the week, including a day of “direct action”, a code name for civil disobedience and anarchic action, on August 31st. While the New York City Police had been remarkably restrained for the first two days of the convention, they lost patience as small groups harassed delegates all over the city. As soon as more than a few people gathered on a street corner, and unfurled signs or began to legally march on the sidewalk, the police simply wrapped the entire area in orange netting and arrested everyone inside. Many members of the press, civilians merely in the wrong place in the wrong time, and peaceful protesters were wrongly detained.

Nearly 1,700 arrestees were taken in city buses to a dirty pier on the Hudson, made to lie on an oily cement floor without padding, and held in excess of the legally mandated 24 hours. The rational for this long wait is either incompetence, or a desire to keep protesters locked up until the President left the city. Either is unacceptable. On Thursday, a New York State judge ordered the the release of those prisoners held for more than 24 hours, and fined the city $1000 per illegally detained person.

I had left the city before the mass arrests began, but did experience some action. I narrowly missed an arrest and perhaps a beating in front of the Broadway theater where my state’s delegates saw the play Bombay Dreams. I was able to converse peacefully with delegates and members of Congress attending a party at a bowling alley late on Sunday night, until the police showed up and cleared the sidewalks under threat of violence.

Some at the Republican Convention questioned the patriotism of the demonstrators. Zell Miller, a renegade Democrat who gave the keynote address on Wednesday, claimed that Kerry’s protest of the Vietnam war “weakened our military.” He said that “it is the soldier, not the agitator, who has given us the freedom to protest.” While the solider does defend that right with his or her blood, the right itself is given to all by the Constitution, and expected as the behavior of an active citizen by our founding fathers. No less a man than Thomas Jefferson stated that “Dissent is the highest form of patriotism.”

While Zell Miller may compare me with a terrorist, dissent is our most important political right, enshrined in the First Amendment. Whatever your views, speak up. Dissent has been curtailed in previous times of war, and it is often the first right to go in dictatorships. To truly honor those who sacrificed themselves defending our freedoms, practice the rights guaranteed to you in the Constitution. Silence is the ultimate act of condonement and defiant dissent its antithesis.

Both political parties claim that this is a defining moment in our history. It couldn’t be more true. While both candidates use remarkably similar language on certain issues, particularly the war, we are faced with a choice between two radically different visions for the future of government. Unlike the last election, where it seemed we were given the choice between Tweedledee and Tweedledum, the choices these two candidates make, and the people they surround themselves with, will take this country in different directions.

Which future you support is your decision, but participation in democracy is not. I don’t care who you vote for, just vote. Request an absentee ballot from your state, read a real newspaper, and make an informed decision. Thanks to the peculiarities of the electoral system, your vote in Massachusetts is meaningless, because the state is guaranteed to go for Kerry. If you want your vote to count, vote by mail.

You don’t have to risk arrest or bodily harm to be a patriot, but you do have to vote.

– Published in today’s Tech

First Post!

This is your standard virtual ego-trip, and a testbed for my knowledge of standards-compliant web design. It’s sparse, but that’s the way I like it. The rollover menus and Quote-o-Matic may not work in IE. Stop complaining and get a real browser.

The photos on the left are slowly coming online. The system for generating the galleries works, but the images themselves are yet to be sorted. At least it gives me something to do while avoiding work.

Visual Versus Verbal

The Forest in the Winter at Sunset (1845-67), Pierre Rousseau, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

“This painting is terrifying,” she said. I had to agree. Two figures, central in the frame, are dwarfed by the literal awesomeness of the forest. The sky is an ominous orange, perhaps because of a fire, or one of those cold winter sunsets, where the cold creeps in as sun descends.

Geese fly overhead, in their classic flying vee. They have the sense and the ability to go south. Where can these pour souls escape to? They have only a narrow path through the tangled brush, puddles to slog through, and precious minutes left of daylight.

As I read the placard accompanying the painting, every tool of analysis from high school english classes comes rushing back from my forgotten memories. The classic types of conflict: man vs. nature, man vs. self, man vs. man. These two hold on to each other to weather the storm. They cooperate against nature. But if the forest is the soul, and the sunset our human frailty, then against whom do we fight? We can’t very well take on the entire world and win.

We walked here from Columbia; first twenty blocks south, then through Central Park, then another ten blocks while we got unlost. She’s supposed to know where she is; at least she lives in this city. I am totally useless without a map and compass. At least this urban jungle is a grid, we have the advantage of several orthogonal paths through the underbrush.

On the path through the park, we passed business men and women exercising themselves. Step out of the office, into this small rectangle of nature, protected by expensive running shoes, goretex jackets and an iPod. Not these two, they run for their very lives. As if they “had the very whips of their masters at their backs.” Perhaps this is Fangorn forest, and one of these crooked trees is an Ent.

“What do you want to do with your life?” I asked, by way of an introduction. “Environmental science,” she replied. How typical, I thought. All of these rich girls want to save the world. I always thought she was more of the physics type, but then she grew her hair long, and her curls became dreads. And I knew we were on different paths through this jungle.

The hunched figures hurry along to make it home alive. I navigate the subway system and try to find 139 Canal Street and the Chinatown bus. I am successful, and catch the last few seconds of the Superbowl in my dorm. Are these two so lucky? No post-victory riot awaits them, only the trial of living one more day. And for that, we are grateful.

—

Wrote this for 21W.730, the writing class I had to take because of my own laziness when taking the Freshman Essay Exam. Note to self, don’t be an idiot, take all written tests seriously.

Page 100 of 100

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén